Showing posts with label oil prices. Show all posts
Showing posts with label oil prices. Show all posts

Saturday, August 2, 2008

Better fuel standards?

A New York Times editorial calls for tougher fuel economy (mpg) standards. They further claim that consumers and the auto industry would be in much better shape, had Congress done so 5, 10 or 20 years ago.

That seems unlikely, given how CAFE is applied in practice. Automakers continue to sell whatever quantity of popular vehicle is being sold, regardless of its fuel efficiency (example: SUVs). Other cars in the fleet are sold to balance out the CAFE standards, occasionally at slim-to-no-profit. Thus, raising federally required fuel efficiency does little to address pollution, carbon, or oil supply/demand problems. If gasoline is always cheap, fuel efficiency only slightly reduces demand. Fuel efficiency combined with cheap gasoline can even increase demand, if the nation collectively feels it can drive more due to owning efficient cars.

If we wish to benefit from hindsight, the best solution is a carbon tax (or price floor), as noted in a fantastic piece by conservative George Will. (Here in America, a conservative calling for a tax is highly unusual)

If a carbon tax had been in place 5, 10, 20 years ago, the oil prices would be the same as today, yet all that additional money would have stayed inside the United States rather than going to Nigeria, Russia, and the Middle East. High oil and gas prices accomplish what decades of environmentalism and government regulation failed to do: raise efficiency, sink SUV sales, and encourage investors to take a serious look at alternative energy.

Calling for tougher CAFE standards will do little. An oil price floor or gasoline price floor will directly accomplish the NYT's desired goals (reducing auto emissions, reducing fossil fuel use, etc.) while also being far more open, honest, transparent, and simple.

Monday, July 21, 2008

Infrastructure and oil prices

Here in North Carolina, gasoline taxes fund roads and public transportation. Cutting taxes, as this story from 2006 describes, directly impacts that infrastructure.

As high oil and gas prices today reduce demand, revenue to maintain that infrastructure decreases.

In a future where personal vehicles don't run on fossil fuels, where will that money come from? The general fund? Bonds? Taxes on electricity and natural gas? Tolls?

My futuristic guess: In the future, you will subscribe to American Super Highways(tm) road service, just like you subscribe to Internet service, thus giving your vehicle or PRT access to that roadway.

In any case, if gasoline-fuelled cars become the minority, that "hidden" cost must be borne elsewhere. This is not a criticism of any particular policy. I'm merely a technocrat wondering aloud about an unsolved problem we must eventually confront.